Keightley, a yeoman’s son brought up on the border of Worcestershire and Staffordshire, came to London at the age of 17 as an apprentice skinner. The fortune that he made through trade elevated him to gentry status, and his funeral monument describes him as the noble restorer of his family.
Keightley’s prominence in the Virginia Company may have been linked to his marriage in 1616, as his wife’s uncle, Sir William Hervey I*, was stepfather to the 3rd earl of Southampton, the Company’s dominant figure.
Keightley helped to finance a voyage to North America during 1621, and remained an active member of the Virginia Company until its dissolution three years later. In December 1623 he was accused of denouncing as ‘neither just nor honest’ the government’s demand for the surrender of the Company’s charter. His accuser, William Canning, who belonged to the rival faction on the board, also assaulted him in the City. However, Keightley was discharged by the Privy Council after producing 24 witnesses, while a London jury awarded him £20 damages for the physical attack.
Keightley apparently focused on his career in the Skinners’ Company during the 1630s, serving twice as warden, and finally becoming master in 1641. He also briefly rejoined the East India Company’s board, but refused to continue after July 1639. He fined for the office of sheriff of London that year, and that of alderman in 1641, though the latter decision was probably influenced by the prevailing political crisis.
Keightley drew up his will on 27 Nov. 1662, bequeathing just £100 to his younger son, and appointing his wife Rose as residual legatee and executrix. It is unclear whether his heir, William, was still in disgrace, but his children were provided with £1,500. Keightley died three months later, and was buried at Hertingfordbury, as he had requested. Rose outlived him by nearly two decades, retaining her ‘very comely’ looks right up until her death. William’s son Thomas married the youngest daughter of the 1st earl of Clarendon (Edward Hyde†), and sat in the Irish House of Commons from 1695 to 1714. However, Keightley was the only member of his family returned to the Westminster Parliament.
