Nottingham, with a population of perhaps 3,500 by 1600, continued to flourish throughout the sixteenth century: both Leland and Camden were impressed by its evident signs of prosperity. The charter granted by Henry VI in 1449, which made the town a county in itself with its own sheriffs and escheator, was confirmed, with little or no change, by every Tudor monarch and remained the basis of government until the reign of Charles II.
The choice of MPs was probably made by the common council alone. Elections were conducted by the two sheriffs ‘in full county court’ in the guildhall, but the surviving returns give no hint that the ordinary burgesses helped to nominate the Members, who were doubtless selected in advance. Apart from the aldermen and recorder, the highest number of burgesses named on a return is 18 in 1584: these were probably councilmen, together with the chamberlains, coroner and other office holders. In 1597 there was a full attendance of aldermen, recorder and councilmen—no one else is mentioned.
Though Nottingham was strong enough to retain the initiative in the choice of MPs, it found it expedient, possibly even desirable, to gratify the wishes of the Manners family, earls of Rutland. The 3rd Earl, and perhaps the 2nd also, was high steward of the borough, and the family held the constableship of Nottingham castle for most, if not all, of the reign. Prior to 1593, when Manners influence disappeared during the 5th Earl’s minority, at least one likely Rutland nominee is to be found in every Parliament save 1571 when the 3rd Earl, who had only just come of age, does not seem to have taken an active interest in elections. John Bateman, who was returned five times between 1555 and 1584, was one of the 2nd Earl’s secretaries until the latter’s death in 1563, when he seems to have entered the household of the 6th Earl of Shrewsbury. Bateman’s colleague in 1559 was Thomas Markham, a Nottinghamshire protestant country gentleman who had sat for the borough in Mary’s first Parliament. His father, who was knight of the shire in 1559, was a great friend of the 2nd Earl of Rutland, and he himself had earlier served the Manners family. Sir Thomas Manners (1572) was the 3rd Earl’s uncle, and Sir Robert Constable (1586) his first cousin and close friend. Constable, whose brother George was in Rutland’s household, had served with Sir Thomas in Scotland in 1570, both being knighted on the same day, and they were the two Nottingham county Members in 1584. George Manners, the son and heir of John Manners of Haddon Hall, Derbyshire, was still a minor when elected to the 1589 Parliament. With the earldom held by a boy, he may have owed his seat to his father’s influence, or to that of one of his uncles, Roger Manners I of Uffington, or (most likely) Sir Thomas, the 1572 Member, who became constable of Nottingham castle in 1588.
All the other Members were townsmen and were probably paid for their services in Parliament. Humphrey Quarnby was mayor at the time of his third election for the borough in 1563. Following his death, his place in the second session was taken by Ralph Barton, the recorder. Barton’s successor Richard Parkins was returned to the four Parliaments from 1584. The other Members include two mayors or town clerks, William Ball (1571) and William Gregory (1601), two aldermen, Humphrey Bonner (1593 and 1597) and Anchor Jackson (1597), and a councilman, William Greaves (1601), who served as coroner for more than 30 years.
