Beaufoy was the exemplar of George Tierney’s contention that ‘the dissenters indeed seldom thrive when they separate from the flock’. He added, ‘It is true he got a place, but he very soon sickened and died’.
Beaufoy was returned after another contest—but a feeble one—at Yarmouth in 1790. On 10 Nov. he was awarded the freedom of the borough as a token of the corporation’s ‘esteem and regard’.
Beaufoy was a witness in the trial of John Horne Tooke in November 1794, when the latter, cross-examining him, regretted that ‘his remembrance required so much flapping’. According to Farington,
Beaufoy’s evidence is considered prevaricating and contemptible; he did not, he said, remember the uniform worn by members of the Association though he was one ... Sir Joseph Banks declared he had seen Beaufoy at his house in that dress many times.
Further, ‘Beaufoy affected to know little of Tooke, though it was to him he applied for advice how he should proceed to get into Parliament when he proposed quitting the vinegar business’. Beaufoy was supposed never to have ‘got over ... the chagrin excited by what Horne Tooke said of him at the Old Bailey, the truth of which he however denied’.
